12 questions to ask a LinkedIn agency before you sign

By Branding PiratesUpdated

Why founders need these questions

Founders who tried a LinkedIn agency and left often tell the same story. On r/b2bmarketing, one founder wrote:

"Thought agencies could handle the manual grind better than us but nope, same spray tactics."

Another reply in the same thread said:

"Yeah most LinkedIn agencies are just renting your account to an automation stack and calling it outbound."

These are single comments with few upvotes, so they do not prove what most agencies do. They do show the two fears that come up again and again: posts that do not sound like you, and DMs from a tool that put your account at risk. The questions below test for both.

Copy them into an email and send the same list to every agency you talk to. Then compare the answers side by side.

Questions about the posts

1. Who writes my posts, and can I talk to that person?

Why ask: many agencies sell with a senior person and hand the writing to someone you never meet.

A good answer: the name and role of the writer, and a regular call with that writer.

2. How do you learn my voice?

Why ask: a SaaS founder on Reddit paid $2,400 for a ghostwriter. In month 4, a prospect said this on a call:

"I almost didn't reach out, your posts didn't match how you talk in person."

A good answer: a talk with you before the first post, and posts written from your calls, notes and real examples. Ask to see one before and after example from another client, with that client's yes.

3. Do I say yes to every post before it goes out?

Why ask: your name is on every post. Nothing should go out that you did not read.

A good answer: yes, with a clear way to change a post and a time limit for your reply.

4. How many posts a month, in writing?

Why ask: a 2026 study of 25 ghostwriting price lists found listings that never say how many posts you get, and "up to" numbers that can mean very little. The study gives this example: "Up to 3 posts a week" can mean 4 posts a month.

A good answer: a fixed minimum number of posts each month, in the contract.

Questions about the replies and DMs

5. Who replies to the comments on my posts?

Why ask: a comment from a buyer is the first step to a call. A reply 3 days later can lose that buyer.

A good answer: who replies, how fast, and how they tell a buyer from a peer.

6. Who sends the DMs: a person or a tool?

Why ask: LinkedIn's User Agreement (section 8.2, item 13) says members must not "use bots or other unauthorized automated methods to access the Services, add or download contacts, send or redirect messages". LinkedIn's help page on invitations says an account can be restricted when it sends many invitations in a short time or when LinkedIn suspects an automation tool.

A good answer: a person writes and sends each DM, and the agency names the tools it uses.

7. How many DMs and connection requests go out each day?

Why ask: high volume is the risk. A founder on r/LinkedInTips whose account was restricted wrote:

"I was risking my account for a 2% response rate on messages nobody wanted to receive."

A good answer: a number for each day and each week, and the reason for that number.

8. How do you get into my account?

Why ask: LinkedIn's User Agreement says, in section 2.2: "You will not share your account with anyone else". Ask how the agency does its work without your password, or what it does if it needs access.

A good answer: a clear method in writing, and you can stop the access at any time.

Questions about the results

9. Who are my buyers, and how will you reach them?

Why ask: a founder on Reddit had 3 months of good engagement and zero clients. One reply said:

"Your content is probably attracting peers, not prospects."

A good answer: a short description of your buyer before the first post, and posts that answer that buyer's problems.

10. What do you report each month?

Why ask: likes are easy to report. A commenter on r/founder wrote that a ghostwriter has to prove they can "deliver business results, not just likes."

A good answer: buyers who commented, DMs sent, replies to the DMs and calls booked, each month.

11. What will you stop doing?

This question comes from a reply on r/EntrepreneurRideAlong:

"Before hiring an agency, I'd ask them to show what they would stop doing, not just what they would post."

A good answer: a short list of things in your current LinkedIn work that do not help you get buyers, for example company news posts that buyers skip.

Questions about the contract

12. How long is the contract, and can I see the work first?

Why ask: the price study found 6 and 12 month minimums, and it says to plan for 3 months before you judge results. A long contract before you see one post is a risk for you.

A good answer: a sample of work before you sign, and a short first contract.

Our answers to the questions

These are our answers today:

QuestionBranding Pirates
1. Who writes my posts?A senior writer, and a designer for the infographics
2. How do you learn my voice?One talk with you about your story, offer and buyers, then your calls and notes
3. Do I say yes to every post?Yes. Nothing goes out without your yes.
4. How many posts a month?24 posts a month.
6. A person or a tool for DMs?A dedicated person sends the DMs. No automation and no tool, because LinkedIn hates automation.
7. How many connection requests a day?35 connection requests a day.
9. Who are my buyers?We write down your buyer with you before the first post.
11. What will you stop doing?We tell you on the free call, after we read your last posts.
12. Contract, and work first?2 gift posts before you pay anything.

Ask us all 12 on the free call

Bring this list to the call and ask us every question. Before the call, see the work for yourself: claim 2 gift posts, each with an infographic, written from your real work.

The gift posts are free. You can post them even if we never work together.

Test us before you talk price.

2 gift posts, each with an infographic, written from your real work. Free, and yours to post.

Questions founders ask us

Is it normal to ask an agency these questions?

Yes. A good agency expects them.

Which question is the most important?

Questions 6 and 7, about who sends the DMs and how many. Your account and your name carry the risk, so you need those answers before anyone sends a message for you.

Do I need to give an agency my LinkedIn password?

LinkedIn's User Agreement says that you will keep your password a secret and not share your account. Ask each agency how it works without your password, and get the answer in writing.

Can I test an agency before I sign?

Ask for a sample. Our sample is 2 gift posts with infographics, free, before any call about price.

Sources

  • Reddit, r/b2bmarketing, "Someone asked if hiring a LinkedIn agency is worth it": reddit.com
  • Reddit, r/EntrepreneurRideAlong, "Trying linkedin marketing services because organic reach is dead for me": reddit.com
  • Reddit, r/LinkedInTips, "I got my LinkedIn account restricted after trying to 'scale' my outreach": reddit.com
  • Reddit, r/SaaS, "I paid $2,400 for a LinkedIn ghostwriter", 22 Mar 2026: reddit.com
  • Reddit, r/socialmedia, "Posting consistently for 3 months on LinkedIn": reddit.com
  • Reddit, r/founder, "Does founders really look for a LinkedIn ghostwriter anymore?": reddit.com
  • LinkedIn User Agreement, sections 2.2 and 8.2, read 31 Oct 2026: www.linkedin.com
  • LinkedIn Help, "Types of restrictions for sending invitations": linkedin.com
  • Shruti Kaushik, "LinkedIn Ghostwriter Cost 2026: Rates From 25 Real Price Lists": shrutikaushik.com

More answers for founders.

All articles